Ryan Michael Sports
Rankings
I'm often asked "What is your criteria for ranking quarterbacks?" The answer is longer than I could hope to summarize in one post. It's not just statistics. It's not just wins, losses and rings. It's not just regular season performance, postseason performance, Championship game performance or voted-on awards. It's all of these things, but so much more. Football is the ultimate team sport and there's really no such thing as "individual" statistics, awards or wins. It's a collective effort and it's a tremendous challenge to attempt to quantify the individual-impact on the results of team-driven football games.
There's no substitute for watching film. Not highlight reels or casual viewing during 1:00 and 4:00 television broadcasts. Studying film is an imperfect science but a great joy if you approach it with an open mind and a desire to consistently improve. Statistics are important, often a footprint of on-field performance, but context is just as important. Totality matters. Windows impress but sometimes mislead. My rankings aren't narrative-based, they're performance-based. "What did you contribute to your team's chances of winning?" matters more to me than end-results bereft of context and touted with certainty.
My rankings are ever-evolving, imperfect and more importantly—just one man's opinion.
—Ryan Michael
50 Greatest Quarterbacks in Pro Football History
Published: 9/9/23
1. Peyton Manning
2. Drew Brees
3. Tom Brady
4. Johnny Unitas
5. Aaron Rodgers
6. Dan Marino
7. Fran Tarkenton
8. Joe Montana
9. Sammy Baugh
10. Brett Favre
11. Steve Young
12. Patrick Mahomes
13. Otto Graham
14. Roger Staubach
15. Sid Luckman
16. Norm Van Brocklin
17. Y.A. Tittle
18. Sonny Jurgensen
19. John Elway
20. Dan Fouts
21. Russell Wilson
22. Benny Friedman
23. Arnie Herber
24. Matt Ryan
25. Ben Roethlisberger
26. Warren Moon
27. Philip Rivers
28. Kurt Warner
29. Bart Starr
30. Jim Kelly
31. Andrew Luck
32. Bobby Layne
33. Ken Anderson
34. Terry Bradshaw
35. Ken Stabler
36. Charlie Conerly
37. Randall Cunningham
38. Joe Namath
39. Tony Romo
40. Troy Aikman